Oaks Financial Services
All guides
Guide · Taxes

What Is a Roth Conversion, and When Is It Worth It?

Roth Conversions

A Roth conversion moves money from a pre-tax IRA or 401(k) into a Roth. You pay the income tax now so the growth and withdrawals are tax-free later. That sounds backwards, until you compare the rate you'd pay today with the rate that money would face later. The years between retirement and Social Security are often the best tax window of your life, but converting isn't right for everyone, and leaving the money alone is a real choice too.

What is a Roth conversion?

A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA or 401(k) into a Roth account. The amount you move gets added to your taxable income this year. You’re settling up with the IRS now. In exchange, that money (and all its future growth) becomes tax-free, and it’s no longer subject to required minimum distributions during your lifetime.

A traditional IRA is a deal with the IRS: you skipped the tax going in, and you owe it coming out, at whatever rate applies in the year the money comes out. A conversion settles that bill early, at today’s rate. So the whole comparison comes down to one question: is the rate you’d pay today lower than the rate you’d pay later? If yes, converting tends to win. If no, leaving it tends to win. The rest of this guide is about working out which is true for you, because it’s rarely obvious from the outside.

When does a Roth conversion make sense?

For many people there’s a stretch (often between retiring and starting Social Security and required withdrawals) when taxable income drops to almost nothing. Career income has stopped; forced income hasn’t started. For a few years, the lowest tax brackets are sitting there, mostly unused.

That’s the classic conversion window. For illustration: a couple retiring at 62 with modest interest income might fill the rest of the 12% bracket with conversions each year for several years: moving six figures out of their traditional IRA at 12%, money that would otherwise have come out at 22% or higher once RMDs and Social Security stack up in their 70s. Same money, meaningfully different lifetime tax bill.

What does leaving the money alone really mean?

Leaving it feels like the safe, do-nothing option. It’s a choice with consequences of its own.

  • The tax bill grows with the account. Every dollar of growth inside a traditional IRA is a dollar the IRS will eventually tax as ordinary income.
  • The IRS sets the schedule. Starting at 73 (75 for younger generations under current law), required minimum distributions force money out every year, whether you need it or not. Big RMDs can push you into higher brackets, make more of your Social Security taxable, and trigger Medicare premium surcharges.
  • The survivor pays single rates. When one spouse dies, the other often pays tax on nearly the same income at single-filer rates, a quiet penalty few people see coming.
  • Your heirs inherit the tax bill. Most non-spouse heirs now have to empty an inherited traditional IRA within ten years, on top of their own income, often in their peak earning years.

None of that makes leaving it wrong. It means “leaving it” is really “letting the calendar pick the rate,” and the calendar isn’t always kind.

Converting during the low-income window shrinks future RMDs, spreads the tax over your cheapest years, and leaves behind Roth money that’s tax-free to you and, within their ten-year window, to your heirs.

What does converting cost, and what should you check first?

  • The tax is due now, in real money: ideally paid from cash outside the IRA, so the full converted amount keeps growing. Paying it from the account works, but it shrinks the amount that gets to grow tax-free.
  • Brackets are edges, not suggestions. Converting $10,000 too much can spill into the next bracket, raise Medicare premiums two years later through IRMAA, or affect ACA health-insurance subsidies before 65. The size of each year’s conversion is the whole game.
  • Conversions are permanent. There’s no undo. That’s why they’re usually done in measured annual slices, not one big leap.
  • It can be the wrong year. Converting while career income is still high means paying a high rate to avoid a rate that might have been lower anyway.

Converting versus leaving it, side by side

  • When the tax is paid: converting, now, at a rate you choose; leaving it, later, at a rate the calendar chooses.
  • Growth from here: converting, tax-free; leaving it, tax-deferred, taxed on the way out.
  • Required withdrawals: converting, none during your lifetime; leaving it, required from 73 or 75.
  • A surviving spouse: converting, tax-free income at any filing status; leaving it, the same income taxed at single rates.
  • Your heirs: converting, tax-free within their ten-year window; leaving it, taxable income stacked on their own.
  • Flexibility: converting, permanent; leaving it, keeps the option open, but the window to convert cheaply may close.
  • The risk you take: converting, paying tax you might not have owed if your later rate turns out low; leaving it, paying more than you needed to because you never used your cheap years.

Who is converting right for?

  • People in the stretch between retiring and starting Social Security and RMDs, when taxable income drops and the lowest brackets sit mostly unused.
  • Anyone whose traditional IRA is large enough that future RMDs would push them into a higher bracket than they’re in today.
  • Married couples who want to protect the survivor from single-filer rates on the same income.
  • People who expect to leave the account to children in their own peak earning years.

Who is leaving it right for?

  • Anyone still in their highest-earning years, where the conversion would be taxed at the top of their career rate.
  • People who genuinely expect to spend the money in retirement at a lower bracket than today, with no large RMD problem looming.
  • Anyone without cash outside the IRA to pay the tax, since paying it from the account itself gives back much of the benefit.
  • People who plan to give from the IRA to charity, where qualified charitable distributions can satisfy RMDs without the income ever appearing on a return.

What do people get wrong?

  • Treating it as all or nothing. The best answer is usually a slice a year, sized to fill a low bracket and stop.
  • Waiting for a “perfect” year that never comes. The low-income window between retirement and Social Security is finite. Once RMDs and Social Security stack up, the cheap years are gone.
  • Converting without running the numbers. This is genuinely personal. The right amount, in the right year, depends on your full picture, which is exactly the kind of math we sit down and do with people, before anything is moved.

Wondering where your own plan stands? The Retirement Blind Spot Check is seven quick questions that show you where your blind spots might be — free, no appointment needed.

Take the 2-minute check

Quick answers

What is a Roth conversion?
Moving money from a traditional IRA or 401(k) into a Roth account. The converted amount is added to your taxable income this year, and in exchange that money and all its future growth become tax-free, with no required minimum distributions during your lifetime.
Is it better to convert to a Roth or leave my money in a traditional IRA?
Convert when the tax rate on the conversion today is lower than the rate that money would face later; leave it when today's rate is higher. For many people the answer is some of each, converted in measured yearly slices during low-income years rather than all at once.
When is the best time to do a Roth conversion?
Often the stretch between retiring and starting Social Security and required withdrawals, when taxable income drops and the lowest brackets sit mostly unused. Converting in those years can move money out at 12% that would otherwise come out at 22% or higher.
What happens if I just leave my traditional IRA alone?
It keeps growing tax-deferred, and so does the tax bill inside it. Starting at 73 (75 for younger generations under current law), required minimum distributions force money out on the IRS's schedule, taxed as ordinary income, whether you need it or not.
Can a Roth conversion be undone, or turn out to be a mistake?
Conversions are permanent, which is why they are usually done in measured annual slices. Converting in a high-income year, converting so much that you spill into a higher bracket or trigger Medicare surcharges, or paying the tax from inside the IRA can all cost more than leaving the money alone.
Do I have to choose all or nothing?
No, and most people shouldn't. A partial conversion each year, sized to fill a low bracket and no more, keeps both buckets working and leaves you with options no matter what tax rates do.
Next step

Understanding the topic is one thing. Seeing how it applies to your own plan is another.

See how this applies to you